Review: In Her Shadow by Mark Edwards

In Her ShadowFor four years Jessica has never doubted that her sister Isabel’s death was an accident. But when Jessica’s young daughter seems to know long-forgotten details about her aunt’s past, Jessica can’t shake the feeling that there’s a more sinister truth behind the tragedy.

As Jessica unearths disturbing revelations about her sister, and about the people she loved and trusted most, it becomes clear Isabel’s life was less than perfect and that Jessica’s might also be at risk.

Did someone murder Isabel? Are they now after Jessica and her family? The key seems to lie in the hands of a child. Can Isabel reveal the truth from beyond the grave, or is the answer closer to home?


I read The Retreat by Mark Edwards early this year. I loved the book so much that I grabbed In Her Shadow immediately it was available. The book didn’t have a cover then and I didn’t need to read the blurb to decide that I had to read it.

In Her Shadow begins five years after Isabel’s death.  Her niece, Olivia,is suddenly talking about the aunt that she never met.  She knows things about Isabel’s life such as her favorite music, the name of her childhood pet. Things that her family hadn’t shared with her This definitely spooks everyone. How does she know all this? Is Isabel visiting her from the next world? In addition, Olivia has now brought suspicions about Isabel’s death. Was it really an accident as everyone believed or did someone else have a hand in it?

Through the dual narrative, readers get to unravel the mystery surrounding Isabel’s death and Olivia’s behavior. Isabel’s narrations presented clues that had me guessing what could have happened to her. However, I couldn’t guess what was going on with Olivia. Having read Mark’s previous books, I knew that there would be an explanation but I was still spooked by some of the stuff the little girl said.

This is a well-paced thriller that had me guessing to the last page. The character development of the sisters was impeccable. I like how Isabel’s character was so well developed even though she only appeared in the story through the past timeline, flashbacks and Olivia’s revelations.  I also like the fact that the story was unpredictable which is something that I enjoy in thrillers.

However, like I mentioned in the first paragraph, my experience with this story was a bit different compared to the author’s previous title. Maybe my expectations were too high? I still loved this story though, just not as much I thought I would. Still, I have nothing but love for Mark’s writing. The vivid imagery, addictive storytelling and even his ability to make things that I don’t believe in, actually seem plausible definitely makes me a big fan of his writing.

Family secrets, obsessions, deception and a mysterious death, perfect cocktail for this disturbing, enthralling thriller that will keep you turning pages in search for answers.

24 thoughts on “Review: In Her Shadow by Mark Edwards

    1. Creepy might be because of the ghost story but it wasn’t very scary, more shocking I think. And yes, this is a great choice though The Retreat is my favorite book by the author so I’d recommend that one and then this one 🙂

  1. I like hearing that it wasn’t obvious what was going on… it’s got my interest and I’m happy to hear that it wasn’t too creepy scary but more confusing it seems. I haven’t read The Retreat either but I believe I’d actually like to read both now ;-). Great review!

  2. Such a lovely and thoughtful review, Diana! I wonder if it helped me a little that I hadn’t read any of his other books first? So I didn’t know how high the bar was set? I’m happy you still enjoyed it overall.

    1. Thanks Jennifer. It would probably help not to compare this one to The Retreat. However, I’d still recommend reading both books if you get the chance 🙂 They are different but both are good in their own ways 🙂

    1. Thank you. I have only read this one and The Retreat but can’t wait to discover more of his books. I really like his style of writing. I hope that you will get a chance to read this one at some point 🙂

  3. Both this and the Retreat are awesome!
    I still have around 9% to go, and wow. I’m buddy reading with my bestie and our messenger is on fire! 😀
    Great review!

    1. Thanks Norrie. I can’t wait to hear your thoughts once you are done. So glad to know that you are both enjoying it so far 🙂 I look forward to your review.

  4. It was my first book from Mark and I just LOVED it to pieces! Fab review! I know what you mean about expectations when you’ve read other things from the author. I always dread the next book won’t be as good, or will be too different etc…

    1. Thanks Meggy and I am so glad that you loved this one so much. I have a feeling that The Retreat will also be a winner for you 🙂

      Yeah, I think that does pose a challenge and then you end up comparing the books. That is what happened to me with this one.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s