Review: My Daughter’s Mistake by Kate Hewitt

In the pretty, privileged college town of Milford, New Hampshire, everyone is friendly, everything is safe. And on this cold autumn day, as red and yellow leaves begin to fall from the trees, and everyone wraps up for the first time, it would be easy to believe nothing bad could ever happen here.

Until a screech of tires is heard, a thud, a child’s scream. The crash that sees Jenna’s six-year-old daughter Amy Rose being hit by a car driven by seventeen-year-old Maddie.

Maddie’s mother, Ellen—a college professor with a warm, approachable reputation—insists it must have been an accident. Her daughter is always safe on the road—and she’s vulnerable herself.

But as Amy Rose lies unconscious in hospital, the town begins to take sides. With Ellen, who just wants to defend her daughter. Or with Jenna, a single mother with a past, whose child hovers between life and death…

The truth is that both mothers have secrets they’re trying to keep. And, with Amy Rose’s life hanging in the balance, one of them will stop at nothing to protect the person she loves—her daughter.


I love Kate Hewitt’s books. They are always quite emotional but I still can’t resist them.

Ellen receives a call from her teenage daughter, Maddie. who has had an accident. The victim is 6-year-old Amy Rose who is quickly rushed to hospital in critical condition. Through the chapters, we see Ellen struggling to support her daughter. She is worried about Amy Rose but as Maddie’s mother, she still has to put her daughter first. On the other hand, the second narrator is Jenna, Amy’s mother. Through her narrative, we follow Amy to the hospital and see doctors try to save her as her mother helplessly stands on the side. She is hurt, angry and scared. Ellen and Jenna are devastated by the position that their daughters are in. However, the 2 women are also hiding secrets. Worse still, Maddie is also hiding a secret about the accident.

This was such a heartbreaking read. The accident scene reminded me of an incident that occurred when I was new driver. I was driving to work on a clear road when suddenly two children in school uniform appeared in front of me, running across the road. They just seemed to have appeared from nowhere. I panicked and instead of hitting the emergency brakes, my foot found the accelerator. When the kids saw the car speeding up to them, they stopped running and just stood rooted on the road staring at me. Mercifully, I was able to stop a few feet from them. Innocently, they waved at me smiling and ran to the other side of the road. Needless to say, I was petrified.

This was a well-narrated story. The two women were quite relatable. I can’t imagine what they were going through but can totally understand the need to protect one’s child at all costs. Such a heartbreaking story overall but I enjoyed the themes of family, forgiveness and motherhood. I was intrigued by all the secrets and the final twist was as beautiful as it was heart-wrenching .

4 thoughts on “Review: My Daughter’s Mistake by Kate Hewitt

  1. I don’t think I could read this one!
    I would have freaked if I was in your position, too! So scary! Not the same thing, but I had a man riding a motorcycle wipe out coming at me the other day. Felt blessed that he didn’t hit me nor did his bike and I was able to stop in time.

    1. So sorry Deanna. That sounds scary too. I am glad that it didn’t end up being an accident. I agree, this was quite a heavy read. I picked it because of the author but wouldn’t have done that if I had read the synopsis before requesting the ARC. I really struggled with the accident though it wasn’t graphically portrayed.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s